Second-hand vs. new: what if brands stopped being afraid?

It’s a question many brands are asking themselves sometimes in a whisper, sometimes out loud in a boardroom:“What if launching our own second-hand offer cannibalizes our new sales?”

It sounds like a fair concern. It touches on the core of the business model, the brand’s positioning, its desirability.

But it’s based on a false assumption. And if you read this article to the end, you’ll see why second-hand doesn’t cannibalize anything it actually enhances everything.

‍

70% of your second-hand buyers... wouldn’t have bought new from you anyway

Here’s the first key point: the vast majority of second-hand shoppers aren’t your new product customers.

They are:

-Young professionals looking for great deals,

-Lovers of rare, one-of-a-kind pieces,

-Consumers who care deeply about the environmental impact of their wardrobe.

In other words: you’re not losing new customers. You’re gaining new ones.

And if you don’t offer them an official alternative, they’ll go elsewhere to Vinted, LeBonCoin, or Vestiaire. You lose the sale, the data, and the opportunity to bring someone into your brand universe.

‍

The virtuous circle no one saw coming

Here’s the second surprise: when a customer resells an item via your own second-hand platform and receives a voucher... they buy something new. In 90% of cases.

The voucher isn’t a loss in value. It’s an invitation to come back. To rediscover your site. To be tempted by something new. It’s a far more effective love letter than a reactivation email or a discount campaign.

‍

And the cherry on top?

Customers who shop with you both new and second-hand are more loyal, more frequent, and more profitable.

Their lifetime value increases. Because they find more than one reason to stay connected to your brand.

‍

Take control of your image, your experience, your insights

When you take ownership of your own second-hand channel, you gain far more than revenue:

-You protect your brand image by avoiding your products getting lost among thousands on third-party platforms,

-You offer a premium experience that aligns with your standards,

-And most importantly, you gather invaluable insights: who sells? What products? At what price? Who buys them?

All this data can fuel decisions in collection planning, merchandising, and CRM.

‍

And if you don’t do it? Someone else will.

Let’s be clear: demand for second-hand exists, whether you want it or not. Third-party platforms already know how to capture that value.

So the question is no longer: “Should we do this?”
But: “How long will we let others profit from our products, our brand, and our customers?”

The real C-word is Control

Launching a second-hand offer means taking back control:

-Of your brand narrative,

-Of your customer experience,

-Of your user data,

-Of the value your products generate—even in their second life.

And if you see a real risk of cannibalization? You can adjust your pricing, target new segments, or fine-tune your strategy. You can’t do any of that if your products are circulating on external marketplaces.

‍

Conclusion: Launching a second-hand offer isn’t a risk. It’s a necessity.

It brings in new customers, reactivates old ones, boosts loyalty. And gives you clearer visibility on your product cycle.

So no, second-hand doesn’t cannibalize.
It complements, enriches, and projects your brand into the future.

As Winston Churchill once said: “Take change by the hand before it takes you by the throat.”

‍

‍

‍